Teen Lesbian Synchonized Swimming
April 26th, 2008
No, no matter how much LCD wishes it was true, this is not a new Olympic sport. The film is called Water Lilies, and it’s directed by Celine Sciamma. It came out in France last year, and its going to get a theatrical release here sometime soon.
The original French title is Naissance des Pieuvres, which translates to “Birth of the Octopuses”. I’m not quite sure where they got that from, or what it actually means in French. But the English title does fit the film.
The story involves a young girl, Marie, struggling with her feelings for an older girl. Marie’s overweight friend, Anne is on a synchronized swim team. During visits to watch her perform, Marie becomes obsessed with Floraine, an older teenager, and the captain of another team.
Anne has her own issues. She yearns to kiss a boy, one in particular, but he happens to be obsessed with bedding Marie. There are never any adults around, and Marie and Anne spend a lot of time together. This changes when Marie starts trying to get close to Floraine.
Floraine has a reputation for being promiscuous. The film hints at affairs she has had with many men. Maybe that is what makes Marie so obsessed with her. The motivations are never clear, and that is where this film falls apart.
Its not that I don’t mind unclear motivations. In fact, thats what drives one of my favorite films. The problem is that the characters in this film do things that feel like they are just to set up some sort of memorable scene.
For example, it feels like the film-makers wanted to make a film full of young teenage sexual tension, so they start the film off with one character already obsessed with another. This leaves out any buildup that would allow the audience to understand more of the characters.
It’s not just the premise. At one point, the older girl, Floraine, falls for another character in the same way. No explanation, it just felt like that was an excuse to get them into bed together, which does happen. Then, after that, she changes her mind again, with no clear reason.
Anne’s story evolves the same way. She is obsessed with a particular boy. They fumble around with sex. Afterwards, she is still obsessed with him, but just before she is about to get the kiss she has longed for she inexplicably changes heart. It’s just too much left unexplained, which really makes the film seemed forced.
The cinematography and directing is great. The film has a nice blue look, and the young girls turn in very great and bold performances. I just felt like the film was exhibiting their young flesh in sexual situations for no other reason than to be edgy and make a memorable film.
It reminded me of Larry Clarke, who makes well-directed films with naked teenagers who give great performances. Water Lilies is the same. It may look good, but without the core of story and character, it falls apart and ends up being an exploitative mess.
Lucky Miles
The last day!!
Another film I was looking forward to was Hong Kong’s 
